One of the top players in team history, Maloney is a 2002 Drew Athletics Hall of Fame inductee who was also named to the Middle Atlantic Conference Hall of Fame in 2020. A 1990 Drew graduate, she remains the program's all-time leader in both goals (70) and points (170). She was honored as a Second Team All-American in 1988, and she was also a three-time All-MAC selection. Upon graduation, Maloney received the College Alumni/ae Association Senior Female Athlete of the Year Award.